What people like
Strong fishy taste is expected
Several reviewers appreciate the natural fishy flavor and say they would buy it again. Some even see the fishy taste as a sign of authenticity.

The 30-second read
What people like
Several reviewers appreciate the natural fishy flavor and say they would buy it again. Some even see the fishy taste as a sign of authenticity.
The main watch-out
One reviewer calls the taste awful and warns that not everyone can drink it. The fishy flavor is strong and may be off-putting.
Before you choose
Some buyers give this to their cats or dogs for health benefits, so consider whether you want it for yourself or a pet.
From a similar, more-reviewed product in this category: Icelandic Cod Liver Oil Softgels - Omega 3 Fish Oil with Vitamin A - 100 Ct
What people like
Reviewers repeatedly say the softgels are easy to swallow and don't leave an unpleasant fishy aftertaste or odor. Many also report benefits like improved energy, balanced cholesterol, and softer coats for pets.
Before you choose
One reviewer uses these softgels for their dog, so it's worth confirming the intended serving size and whether the product suits your specific use case before buying.
The main watch-out
Reviews are overwhelmingly positive; the only real caveats are that one user takes it with a multivitamin and another notes benefits are only "from what I can tell."
Your use case first
10 of 65 mentions describe a negative experience (15%).
0 of 10 mentions describe a negative experience (0%).
0 of 7 mentions describe a negative experience (0%).
20 of 53 mentions describe a negative experience (38%).
5 of 10 mentions describe a negative experience (50%).
5 of 10 mentions describe a negative experience (50%).
3 of 7 mentions describe a negative experience (43%).
4 of 7 mentions describe a negative experience (57%).
One review can mention several topics. Percentages describe the reviews we analysed, not all buyers or the product's overall failure rate.
From a similar, more-reviewed product in this category: Icelandic Cod Liver Oil Softgels - Omega 3 Fish Oil with Vitamin A - 100 Ct
10 of 104 mentions describe a negative experience (10%).
7 of 91 mentions describe a negative experience (8%).
2 of 76 mentions describe a negative experience (3%).
13 of 68 mentions describe a negative experience (19%).
0 of 42 mentions describe a negative experience (0%).
3 of 32 mentions describe a negative experience (9%).
3 of 29 mentions describe a negative experience (10%).
7 of 24 mentions describe a negative experience (29%).
Compare the trade-offs
A random selection of analyzed products from the same category. Different products are not necessarily interchangeable.

Pentadecanoic Acid 300mg 60 Capsules

Viva Naturals Triple Strength Omega 3 Fish Oil Pills – 2500 mg High-Potency Formula with 2250 mg Omega 3 Fatty Acids (Including EPA, DHA, DPA) in rTG Form for Absorption – IFOS Certified, 90 Softgels

Vthrive Premium Wild Alaskan Fish Oil with Vitamin D3 - Supports Cardiovascular Health - 1,375 DHA/EPA (60 Softgels)
Check the evidence
Included does not mean verified authentic. Flagged does not mean proven fake. These are analytical classifications.
Showing 3 illustrative excerpts, not the complete review set.
Oh. My. GOSH! This is awful! How could it get a 5 Star Review?
“So you wanna improve your health. Supposedly. You heard drinking some sort of primordial ooze would do wonders and you thought, why not give it a go. Well pal, you better think again. There is nobody on the face of this earth that can drink this unless (of course) you like drinking ground up fish remnants. But hey, who's to argue with the science, right? Fish pills are all over the place. Little pills you can pop like a PEZ and you think your health is gonna improve, right? Of course not. That's why you're considering this vile concoction. You want, "the stuff". Let's agree that the exact same "stuff" your mom forced you to drink when she heard you swearing and there was no soap in the house to stick down your throat so she used THIS as punishment to teach you lesson! Back then you thought, Dear God Almighty...I never wanna taste that again as long as I live! But now you're thinking, why did mom have this putrid dirge in the house to begin with? Well, because MOM'S KNOW BEST! I'm not going to get into the benefits of Cod Liver Oil or the fact that Cod Liver Oil will prolong your life by 50 years. Er. Ah... maybe not. Nor, will I get into the benefits of eating raw goat organs. But Cod Liver Oil is miraculous, says the internet. So if you're considering this you know the benefits and have the courage of a chihuahua verses the mailman, so let's figure out how to slug down this repulsive gruel without you ending up with your kitchen walls spewed with projectile vomit. Actually, it's quite simple. All you need to do is take a swig of some vegetable juice, the spicer the better. Oh, heck with that! Grab a bottle of your favorite bloody Mary mix, take a drink, don't swallow, hold it in your mouth, and then take a big tablespoon of mom's revenge, and suck it all down. GULP! Adding vodka is up to you. There...Was that so bad? Yes. YES. IT. WAS. But it wasn't as bad as if you drank it alone. You'll say to yourself, Hey, I did it! But your breath will still smell like a farmers that's been in a hot field all day long sucking on carp jerky. And you better not get any of it on your hands because, you ain't gettin it off.”
Signals matched: Mentions: taste, health benefits
BOUGHT IT FOR MY CAT: SHE APPROVED!
“WELL....I'm not sure where to start, really, because this product was for my cat's health, as well as her taste for trout. For some reason, she loved her trout, until she didn't. A friend suggested cod liver oil works well for her cats, enticing them to eat when they decide finicky is their mood of the day. I do smell that "fishy" odor I particularly don't like, but my little girl didn't seem to care and still ate it just fine. I can only imagine that it also tastes fishy. The ingredients are definitely something she needs in her diet. We all do, in fact, but since I can't get her to eat raw, fresh fish (such as what they eat in the wild), this is the next best thing. Value for the money...yes, it is one of the less expensive ones, but I will say that for the reason I bought it, it's done the job. My cat did love it at first, and then, as she got used to it, she seems to back off a bit. Never completely, though; however, this is also her nature. I always say, "She loves / likes it, UNTIL she doesn't."”
Signals matched: Specific detail: scenario · Mentions: odor, taste, health benefits · Reads as an authentic voice
With this oil, I'm never going back to my canned cod liver ways of the past ever again.
“I have no problem with the fishy taste. In fact, I'd have more of a problem if it didn't taste fishy, because if it didn't, It would raise my suspicions about what exactly is in the bottle. An oil extracted from fish guts probably shouldn't taste like canola oil. So if I buy cod liver oil and it doesn't taste fishy, then something smells fishy to me, and it's not the oil. Also, the fish taste isn't even that strong. It's like the oil from canned tuna, sardines, kippers, etc. I don't have lab equipment to test the composition, but I've gone through many different brands over the years and this matched my expectations. Also, I prefer this version compared to those with added lemon or orange flavors because the artificial flavor is very pronounced and really clashes with the meals I try to incorporate the oil into, while this version just blends in and disappears. Overall, I'm happy with this oil and will make it my main brand from now on. I think it's the best deal in Amazon for Cod liver oil.”
Signals matched: Specific detail: comparison · Mentions: taste, ingredients · Reads as an authentic voice
One less thing to search
Customers describe it as having a mild fishy flavor, similar to tuna, and some note it is more palatable than artificial flavors like mint or lemon. One reviewer said they would be more suspicious if it did not taste fishy.
No, the manufacturer lists the flavor as unflavored, and a customer noted that unflavored cod liver oil is harder to find.
Yes, the manufacturer states it supplies potent omega-3 essential fatty acids, notably EPA and DHA, and is also rich in vitamins A and D.
The manufacturer states it is micro-filtered using a 10-step molecular distillation process to remove toxins such as mercury, lead, PCBs, and dioxins, and that products are verified with third-party, FDA-registered agencies.
Some customers report giving it to their cats and dogs, with one saying their dog tolerates it well and another saying a friend suggested cod liver oil for finicky cats.
From a similar, more-reviewed product in this category: Icelandic Cod Liver Oil Softgels - Omega 3 Fish Oil with Vitamin A - 100 Ct
Yes. Multiple reviewers describe the softgels as easy to swallow, and one notes they are "way to swallow" with no upset stomach.
Reviewers report no unpleasant fishy aftertaste and describe them as not leaving an aftertaste or stink.
Each serving contains 1,000 mg of molecularly distilled cod liver fish oil, rich in Omega-3s, EPA, and DHA, plus vitamins A and D3.
The manufacturer recommends taking two softgels daily with food for optimal absorption, and advises consulting your doctor before use if pregnant, nursing, having a seafood allergy, on medication, or having a medical condition. Not intended for children.
One reviewer specifically reports no upset stomach while taking them.
Answers are limited to the manufacturer's listing and the reviews we analysed. Questions those sources cannot support are not answered here.
Transparent by design