Question 1

Does this trash can actually keep odors contained, or is that just marketing?**

Accepted Answer

Many buyers find the odor protection effective for everyday kitchen waste. The lid includes a replaceable carbon filter that helps neutralize smells. However, as a few TikTok reviews note, for the best seal, ensure the lid is fully flush with the rim—some units can arrive slightly misaligned, which reduces effectiveness. For very strong or lingering odors (like fish or diapers), users recommend pairing it with a scented bag.

Question 2

I’ve heard the lid can be loud. Is it really that bad?**

Accepted Answer

It’s a common point of discussion online. The lid does not have a soft-close mechanism, so if you let it drop from a high angle, it will make a noticeable plastic-on-plastic thud. However, if you lower it gently with your foot, it’s quite quiet. For light sleepers or parents of infants, this is worth noting; otherwise, most users find it tolerable for the price.

Question 3

Do I have to buy Glad brand trash bags for the bag ring to work?**

Accepted Answer

No, but it works best with thicker, tall-kitchen bags. The retention ring is designed to hold bags taut and keep them hidden. Many users on Reddit report success with store-brand drawstring bags, but very thin or generic bags can slip off easily. If you’re a fan of a specific budget brand, you might need a quick test to see if they grip well.

Question 4

How does the foot pedal feel? I’ve seen mixed things about it breaking.**

Accepted Answer

For a plastic step can, the pedal is generally well-reviewed for its smooth, responsive action. However, some long-term reviews mention that the pedal can become slightly stiff or less springy after a year of heavy use. It’s not prone to snapping, but it’s not industrial-grade. Expect it to hold up well for daily household use, but it may not suit a high-traffic commercial setting like a large breakroom.

Question 5

I’m comparing this to a Simplehuman can. Is the Glad worth it instead?**

Accepted Answer

This is the most common pre-purchase dilemma. The Glad is an excellent choice if you value a lower price point, a solid bag-holding system, and a lightweight plastic build that’s easy to move. The Simplehuman is better if you prioritize a durable stainless steel finish, a smoother soft-close lid, and a slightly more robust pedal. In short: choose Glad for value and function; choose Simplehuman if aesthetics and near-silent operation are your top priority.

Glad 13 Gallon Trash Can | Plastic Kitchen Waste Bin with Odor Protection of Lid | Hands Free with Step On Foot Pedal and Garbage Bag Rings, Black

Analysis Details

Was this analysis helpful?

What are you buying this for?

Have questions about this product? Ask the community.