Question 1

Are these bags genuinely leak-proof and tear-resistant? I have a large breed dog.**

Accepted Answer

Yes, absolutely. This is the most praised feature in over 212,000 reviews. The bags are extra-thick and designed to handle even runny messes without leaking or tearing during pickup. Many users with large breeds specifically commend their reliability, so you can use them with confidence.

Question 2

Will the lavender scent attract my dog or fade too quickly?**

Accepted Answer

The lavender scent is designed to mask odors for you, not attract pets. It's generally well-loved for this purpose. While most users find the scent pleasant and effective, a small number on forums like Reddit have noted it can fade over time in the package. We recommend storing them in a cool, dry place to maintain the fragrance longest.

Question 3

I have a generic poop bag dispenser from Amazon. Will these refill rolls fit?**

Accepted Answer

In most cases, yes—they fit standard dispensers. However, a common note from user reviews is that some holders, especially rigid, brand-specific models, can be a tight fit. If your dispenser has a narrow core, you might need to re-roll the bags slightly. For guaranteed compatibility, many happy customers pair these with Earth Rated's own dispenser.

Question 4

What makes these worth it compared to cheaper bags from the grocery store?**

Accepted Answer

The difference is in reliability and peace of mind. Cheaper bags are often thin, prone to tearing, and can leak. These bags are an investment in avoiding messy, unpleasant accidents. As one TikTok reviewer put it, "It's cheap insurance against a disaster." The high count (270 bags) also offers better long-term value than small, flimsy packs.

Question 5

Is Earth Rated a Canadian company, and what are they doing for the environment?**

Accepted Answer

Yes, Earth Rated is a Canadian company. They are transparent about using recycled materials where possible in their packaging and products. While the bags themselves are durable plastic (for guaranteed leak-proof performance), they actively partner with organizations like the National Forest Foundation. For a fully compostable option, they offer a separate product line.

Earth Rated (A Canadian Company), Poop Bags for Dogs, Guaranteed Leak Proof and Extra Thick Waste Bag Refill Rolls, Lavender Scented, 270 Count

Analysis Details

Was this analysis helpful?

What are you buying this for?

Have questions about this product? Ask the community.