Question 1

How do I choose the right size for my shoe? The “size-specific” feature sounds confusing.**

Accepted Answer

Crankbrothers recommends Small for shoe sizes up to US 10 and Large for sizes US 10.5 and above. However, many Reddit users note that thick-soled trail shoes (like Five Tens) can affect fit—if you wear bulky footwear, consider sizing up. For the best grip, match the pedal width to your foot’s widest point.

Question 2

Are these pedals durable for aggressive trail riding or heavy riders?**

Accepted Answer

For casual riding and cross-country, they hold up fine. But TikTok users and mechanics warn that the pins can bend or fall out on rocky descents, and the bearings may develop play under riders over 200 lbs. If you ride hard, consider upgrading to a model with thicker axle bolts and sealed cartridge bearings.

Question 3

Can I use these pedals with regular sneakers, or do I need special shoes?**

Accepted Answer

You can use any flat-soled shoe, but performance varies. Many buyers report that soft sneakers let the pins dig in well, while hard-soled work shoes slip. For best results, pair with a stiff cycling flat shoe. If you’re just commuting, generic sneakers will work—just expect less grip.

Question 4

What’s the return policy if I don’t like them?**

Accepted Answer

Crankbrothers offers a 1-year warranty against manufacturing defects but doesn’t cover normal wear (like bent pins). Most retailers accept returns within 30 days if unused, but once mounted, some charge a restocking fee. Buy from a shop with a generous return policy to avoid hassle.

Question 5

How do these compare to RaceFace Chester or OneUp pedals?**

Accepted Answer

The Stamps are slimmer and lighter than the Chester, with a more modern look. But the Chester has a better reputation for long-term durability, and OneUp pedals have more secure pin retention. If you ride mostly pavement or smooth trails, the Stamps are fine. For aggressive or wet conditions, many riders regret not going with OneUp or Deity.

Crankbrothers Stamp Flat MTB Pedals - Size-Specific, Lightweight, Versatile, Durable Bike Pedals

Analysis Details

Was this analysis helpful?

What are you buying this for?

Have questions about this product? Ask the community.