Question 1

How do I stop the lids from leaking or popping off when I fill the trays?**

Accepted Answer

Many users have found that filling the tray slightly less than full—leaving a small air gap at the top—helps the lid snap on securely. You can also freeze the trays flat on a baking sheet for the first hour to set the ice before stacking them. If your lids still won't stay sealed, check that the rim is completely dry before attaching—silicone grips better without moisture.

Question 2

I saw on TikTok that these cubes melt fast. Are they actually good for cocktails?**

Accepted Answer

This is a fair point. These molds produce small, standard ice cubes that melt noticeably faster than larger "whiskey rocks" or sphere molds. They work wonderfully for iced coffee, juice, or kid-friendly drinks where quick dilution is fine. For serious cocktails or spirits, we recommend looking for 2-inch cube molds or silicone ice ball makers instead.

Question 3

The silicone smells like my freezer. How can I get rid of the odor?**

Accepted Answer

Silicone can absorb odors, but it's reversible. Soak the trays in a mixture of hot water and baking soda (2 tablespoons per cup of water) for 30 minutes, then rinse thoroughly. For stubborn smells, follow up with a vinegar rinse. Many TikTok users also recommend freezing lemon juice in the trays once—the citrus neutralizes lingering odors naturally.

Question 4

Will these trays fit in my standard freezer drawer or built-in ice maker compartment?**

Accepted Answer

Each tray measures approximately 10.5 x 5 x 1.5 inches, making them compact enough to fit most standard freezer shelves and drawers. However, they may not fit in narrow built-in ice maker compartments (check your freezer's manual for clearance). They stack beautifully when full, so you can store multiple trays in a small footprint.

Question 5

I only received one tray in my package. Can I get a refund or replacement?**

Accepted Answer

If you received a single tray instead of the advertised set of two, contact the seller through the platform where you purchased it. Most retailers honor their listings and will send a replacement or issue a full refund. Keep your shipping label and photos of the package as proof. For Amazon purchases specifically, their A-to-Z Guarantee covers missing items like this.

Ice Cube Tray – Small Silicone Molds with Lids, BPA-Free and Flexible for Cocktails and Beverages – Set of 2

Analysis Details

Was this analysis helpful?

What are you buying this for?

Have questions about this product? Ask the community.