Question 1

Do these shoes fit true to size, and how should I choose if I have wide feet?**

Accepted Answer

Most riders recommend sizing up at least half a size, especially if you have wider feet or plan to wear thicker cycling socks. The toe box runs narrow compared to standard athletic shoes. If you're between sizes, go with the larger option. Several riders on cycling forums mentioned that going up a full size solved the "pinched toes" problem without compromising heel hold.

Question 2

Are SPD cleats included with the shoes?**

Accepted Answer

No, cleats are not included in the box. These shoes are compatible with standard two-hole SPD-style cleats (like Shimano SH51 or SH56), but you'll need to purchase them separately. The shoes feature the recessed mounting pattern, so once cleats are installed, you can walk relatively comfortably – though these are best kept for short cafe stops rather than long hikes.

Question 3

How stiff is the sole, and can I use these for casual riding and walking?**

Accepted Answer

The sole is deliberately stiff for efficient power transfer, which makes them excellent for gravel and trail riding. However, that stiffness means they are not ideal for extended walking or commuting. If you're planning to walk a lot, many TikTok reviewers recommend looking at a more flexible touring-style shoe. If you're riding 90% and walking 10%, these will serve you well.

Question 4

What kind of durability can I expect, especially with the closure system?**

Accepted Answer

The outsole and upper are quite durable for the price point, with many users reporting 1–2 years of regular weekend riding without significant wear. The main weak point is the Velcro strap, which can lose grip after several months of heavy use. It's still replaceable, but if you're a daily rider, you might consider a shoe with a ratchet or BOA system for longer-term reliability.

Question 5

Are these shoes suitable for beginners who are new to clipless pedals?**

Accepted Answer

Absolutely. These are often recommended as a budget-friendly entry point into SPD pedals. The stiff sole makes it easier to feel connected to the bike, and the price means you're not over-investing while you figure out if clipless riding is for you. Just be patient during the first few rides – there's a learning curve, but starting with a shoe that fits well makes the transition much smoother.

Tommaso Montagna Men’s Mountain Bike Shoes for SPD Pedals – Gravel & Trail Cycling Shoes – Compatible with SPD Cleats – No Cleats Included

Analysis Details

Was this analysis helpful?

What are you buying this for?

Have questions about this product? Ask the community.