Question 1

What exactly does “Renewed” mean for this HP printer, and can I expect it to look and perform like new?**

Accepted Answer

“Renewed” means the printer has been professionally inspected, cleaned, and tested by a third-party refurbisher. Most units look close to new, but based on user feedback, some may arrive with light cosmetic scuffs or residual toner dust. Performance-wise, it should print, scan, and copy at full factory speeds. If the condition bothers you, most sellers offer a 30–90 day return window—check the specific listing’s policy before buying.

Question 2

I’ve read online that the HP Smart app can be finicky for setup—how easy is it to get this printer on Wi-Fi?**

Accepted Answer

That’s a common pain point, especially for first-time users. While the printer supports Wi-Fi, the HP Smart app can be glitchy on certain networks. Many TikTok and Reddit users recommend setting it up via the printer’s touchscreen using WPS (Wi-Fi Protected Setup) instead of the app—it’s faster and more reliable. If you still get errors, a wired USB connection during initial setup solves most issues.

Question 3

Does this printer come with toner, and can I use cheaper third-party cartridges after the starter runs out?**

Accepted Answer

Yes, the printer ships with a standard-capacity toner cartridge (typically about 2,000–3,000 pages). After that, you can use HP 26X (high-yield) cartridges, which cost more upfront but last longer. Many users do use third-party toner—just be aware that HP firmware updates may occasionally flag non-HP cartridges as “non-genuine.” Most of the time they work fine, but there’s a small compatibility risk.

Question 4

I need color printing—will this all-in-one handle that?**

Accepted Answer

No—this model is strictly a black-and-white laser printer. The “all-in-one” feature refers to its print, scan, copy, and fax capabilities, not color output. A common regret among buyers is assuming it prints color documents. If you need occasional color for charts or photos, you’d be better off with a color laser like the Canon MF743Cdw or an inkjet all-in-one.

Question 5

How reliable is the fax function, and is this machine good for a busy small office?**

Accepted Answer

The fax works well for low-to-moderate volume—about 4 pages per minute for transmission. For a busy office scanning or faxing 50+ pages daily, you might find it slower than expected. However, for general office use (printing contracts, scanning documents, sending the occasional fax), it’s a solid, cost-effective workhorse. Just be prepared for slightly slower scan speeds compared to the brand-new version.

HP LaserJet Pro MFP 4101fdw Wireless Black & White Printer with Fax (Renewed)

Analysis Details

Was this analysis helpful?

What are you buying this for?

Have questions about this product? Ask the community.